But as nothing is to be observed in diseases that must be removed in order to change them into health besides the totality of their signs and symptoms, and likewise medicines can show nothing curative besides their tendency to produce morbid symptoms in healthy persons and to remove them in diseased persons; it follows, on the one hand, that medicines only become remedies and capable of annihilating disease, because the medicinal substance, by exciting certain effects and symptoms, that is to say, by producing a certain artificial morbid state, removes and abrogates the symptoms already present, to wit, the natural morbid state we wish to cure. On the other hand, it follows that, for the totality of the symptoms of the disease to be cured, a medicine must be sought which (according as experience shall prove whether the morbid symptoms are most readily, certainly, and permanently removed and changed into health by similar or opposite medicinal symptoms(1)) has a tendency to produce similar or opposite symptoms.
FN
(1) The other possible mode of employing medicines for diseases besides these two is the allopathic method, in which medicines are given, whose symptoms have no direct pathological relation to the morbid state, neither similar nor opposite, but quite heterogeneous to the symptoms of the disease, is, as shown above, in the introduction (Review of the therapeutics, allopathy and palliative treatment that have hitherto been practiced in the old school of medicine), merely instinctive vital force, which, when made ill by noxious agents, strives to save itself at whatever sacrifice by the production and continuance of morbid irritation in the organism - an imitation, consequently, of the crude vital force which was implanted in our organism in order to preserve our life in health, in the most beautiful harmony; but when deranged by disease, was so constituted as to admit of being again changed to health (homoeopathically) by the intelligent physician, but not to cure itself, for which the little power it possesses is so far from being a pattern to be copied, that all the changes and symptoms it produces in the (morbidly deranged) organism are just the disease itself. But this injudicious system of therapeutics of the old school of medicine can no more be passed by unnoticed that can history omit to record the thousands of years of opposition to which mankind has been subjected under the irrational, despotic Governments.
* * * * *
SUMMARY
The Role of Symptoms in Disease Treatment and Medicine Selection
Understanding Disease and Symptoms
- Symptoms as Disease Indicators:
- Diseases are identified and understood solely through the totality of their signs and symptoms.
- For a cure, medicines must address these symptoms by creating an artificial morbid state that eliminates the existing natural morbid state (disease).
Medicines as Curative Agents
- Medicinal Action in Health and Disease:
- Medicines show their curative power by producing specific symptoms in healthy individuals and removing those same symptoms in diseased individuals.
- A medicine becomes a remedy when it excites certain symptoms that counteract the natural disease symptoms present in the patient.
Choosing the Right Medicine
- Criteria for Selection:
- A medicine must be selected based on whether its effects produce symptoms most similar or opposite to the disease’s symptoms, depending on which approach is proven to be more effective by experience.
Critique of Allopathic Medicine
Allopathic Method's Limitations:
- Allopathy employs medicines whose effects are unrelated to the disease symptoms (neither similar nor opposite). These remedies are based on instinctive reactions of the body rather than a rational, targeted approach.
- The body’s natural reaction to disease cannot be relied upon to cure itself, as these reactions (symptoms) are simply the disease manifesting itself.
Role of Intelligent Physicians:
- It is the job of an intelligent physician to intervene with carefully selected remedies rather than imitating the body’s flawed attempt to heal, which often worsens the condition.
Historical Context
- Criticism of Traditional Methods:
- The old school of medicine relied on irrational and ineffective practices that failed to properly address the symptoms of disease, often exacerbating the patient's condition. This mirrors the long-standing opposition to progress seen in other historical contexts.
